what makes a webcomic Great/popular...

[GabrielsThoughts]

ok, I think the WMAWCP list needs an update... and for starters first rule, it has to seem "plausible." Wait, no... who the heck am I kidding. anything goes.  good or bad, if you think it would make a web comic Popular  shout it out.

and no obvious ones such as:

Big Breasted Girls

Chibi

Cheerleaders

Murderous Mayham

Mythological creatures

Paragators

SMUT

Super heroes

Transformers (giant robots etc.)

Transgender (like the wotch)

Violence

as they have already been listed by me.

[techmaster-glitch]

...What's WMAWCP?

[Tapewolf]

...What's WMAWCP?

It looks like an acronym for What Makes A Web Comic Popular.  It may be referring to some previous thread.

[Tiger_T]

nice artwork
telling a good enthralling story
having a sound world design
no plotholes
creativity

They're more like meta-reasons...
Does it still count?

[GabrielsThoughts]

Sure, like I said earlier, "anything goes."

But  was thinking more along the lines of silly.... something like

" pink ninja monkeys from outer space "

" cute talking animals with rabbies"

My hope was to make a game combing this  http://www.missmab.com/Comics/Vol_172.php   with this http://www.bored.com/filmcliches/index.htm

I guess it didn't work out, or I didn't explain it well enough.

[Tiger_T]

Maybe a [Space Pirate Amazon Ninja Catgirl]...