The Lightning Thief Movie

[JackTheCubiWolf]

It's true, I saw a preview for it on the Ice Age 3 movie DVD. It's directed by the guy who directed the first 2 Harry Potter Movies. Now I actually haven't read the book yet but I will as soon as it is returned to my school's library. It's set for a release date oh President's Day 2010.

[Angel]

I read all the books before there was even talk of a movie, so I'm stoked. But if they don't get it right, FAN-GRIPING WILL ENSUE RARGH.

Anyways, go read the books if you haven't yet, they're all very good.

[Rakala]

Any movie they base off of a book will have some fan griping. Whether it's "Oh you didn't include everything" or "You stuck too rigidly to the book" there will always be a little bit. Not necessarily from you but in general.

[Caswin]

Any movie they base off of a book will have some fan griping. Whether it's "Oh you didn't include everything" or "You stuck too rigidly to the book" there will always be a little bit. Not necessarily from you but in general.

What would be an example of sticking too close to the book?  I can certainly understand cutting out pieces (the first Harry Potter movie alone comes to mind), but I can't think of much in the way of being too rigidly faithful.  That sounds like a good movie.

[Rakala]

I'm not saying that's what I think, I'm saying I've heard that complaint before.

[Janus Whitefurr]

What would be an example of sticking too close to the book?  I can certainly understand cutting out pieces (the first Harry Potter movie alone comes to mind), but I can't think of much in the way of being too rigidly faithful.  That sounds like a good movie.

I've only ever heard this attributed to Watchmen, for sticking too faithfully to the graphic novel as best it could. The reasoning behind the critic I read saying it was that it alienated new viewers too much. *shrug*

[Angel]

I've only ever heard this attributed to Watchmen, for sticking too faithfully to the graphic novel as best it could. The reasoning behind the critic I read saying it was that it alienated new viewers too much. *shrug*

Really? I've heard Alan Moore fans complain that it left WAY too much out, though I personally think it did as best a job as it could. Sure, they couldn't include the Black Freighter scenes, and that was a letdown, and sure they changed Laurie's big realization on Mars up a bit, but most of it was pretty good. Either way, I guess both sides have a solid argument in some cases, but Alan Moore still isn't happy.

[Alondro]

Hmm, I've never heard of the "Lightning Thief".  I'll have to examine it.

Is it, like, a fictional version of Benjamin Franklin, that he's a mage who steals lightning with his magical kite?  And has to battle King George's evil legions of dark magicians for control over the power of the New World and bring freedom to the world from the evil British Empire.  *thinks*  Actually... dude.... DUUUUDE!!!  That would totally work!  King George could even be all Sith Lord-ish and everything!  *starts writing!*  It'll be as good as Twilight!   

I'm rather out of the loop of most fiction books written in the last 20 years, unless they've been in the media long enough for me to see headlines.

I work too much. 

[Moonchylde]

I'm not saying that's what I think, I'm saying I've heard that complaint before.

LOTR: The Two Towers, is a perfect example. Mainly because (and I'm saying this as a huge Tolkien fan), T3 was a long, drawn-out snooze-fest that read more like a military tacticians manual then a fantasy novel, and this translated into similar 3+ hour movie.

Then again, if they had cut it, people would've whined that it wasn't faithful to the book. You can never please the entire fan-base. NEVER.

[Janus Whitefurr]

Really? I've heard Alan Moore fans complain that it left WAY too much out, though I personally think it did as best a job as it could. Sure, they couldn't include the Black Freighter scenes, and that was a letdown, and sure they changed Laurie's big realization on Mars up a bit, but most of it was pretty good. Either way, I guess both sides have a solid argument in some cases, but Alan Moore still isn't happy.

The Black Freighter scenes got their own DVD release as an animated thing, I believe, so I have no idea where people would stand on that. There were a few changes (I'd have loved to see the giant psychic death squid, honestly) but the movie was still well put together and relatively faithful to its source. They didn't, say, turn Rorscach into a pure and noble hero character.

As for Alan Moore not being happy, he never IS if his stuff is adapted, last I looked :u